Umpire for no-ball will work well, says Harsha Bhogle

no image

Harsha Bhogle has reckoned that the move to include an off-field umpire in order to check for no-balls during a match would be working well for the future of the game. However, Bhogle would prefer the responsibility be handed over to the third umpire, rather than a dedicated fourth umpire.

Ever since Sourav Ganguly was elected as the president of the BCCI, he has put forward one new proposal after another. Under his initiative, India will play their first-ever day-night Test match on Friday, against Bangladesh. Another prospect that the former India captain has suggested is the use of a dedicated fourth umpire to check no-balls come the next season of the IPL — and Bhogle agrees, to the principle, at least.

“There’s some cricketing issues that he (Ganguly) has brought up that are worthy of a debate. One of those is that we have an additional umpire merely to check no-balls, especially in T20 cricket, where the implications of a wrong no-ball call can be immense. Maybe, for all these years, people were bowling no-balls and we just weren’t checking them. As soon as we had the replays, we discovered that the umpire’s job was very difficult,” Bhogle said in a video shared by Cricbuzz.

“My thought is that we don’t need an extra umpire for that because the third umpire doesn’t have a lot to do anyway. The third umpire, along with a technician, will know in two or three seconds whether or not it is a no-ball, and we’re up and running,” Bhogle added.

The 58-year-old further noted that the issue has surfaced more because the umpires had begun erring on the side of the video replays confirming the decision for them.

Comments

Leave a comment

0 Comments

read previousAsia Cup | Twitter reacts as Hong Kong batter Anshy Rath becomes victim of umpiring howler
It is rare to see both batters in the middle undergo a brainfade, but the Hong Kong openers suffered the same during their Asia Cup 2025 game against Afghanistan. Anshy Rath failed to take the review, though there was a huge gap between bat and ball, after he was given out caught behind.
NZ vs ENG | Sam Curran hopeful of not being vulnerable and cementing his Test spotread next
Left-arm pacer Sam Curran is motivating himself to cement his place in the England Test side by trying to be less vulnerable and more consistent with his performances. Curran was the man of the series against India in the Test series last summer but since then, he has been in and out of the side.
View non-AMP page